The Secret of Station House No. 4
Location: Toronto, Canada
Date Played: July 9, 2026
Team Size: up to 12 players; we recommend 4-6
Duration: 60 minutes (90 minutes for the overall experience)
Price: $46.35 CAD per player on weekdays, $58.71 CAD per player on weekends
Ticketing: Public
Accessibility Consideration: All players must climb a flight of stairs to get to the game space
Emergency Exit Rating: [A+] No Lock
Physical Restraints: [A+] No Physical Restraint
REA Reaction
Murdoch Mysteries is the official escape room adaptation of the Canadian detective television series of the same name. It presented a thoughtful tribute to the source material, intelligible to fans of the show and aspiring detectives alike.
Located in the Coachman’s Stable House on the Casa Loma grounds, Murdoch Mysteries lived in a historical setting that was instantly fitting for the time period. While perhaps not as flashy as the castle towers, the space was well chosen for the theme, and vice versa. Meticulously costumed actors and well-sourced props further brought the world to life.

Like each of Secret City’s experiences at Casa Loma, Murdoch Mysteries featured a mix of immersive theater and puzzle-centric escape room. The actors were seasoned improvisers and talented performers. It never felt like they were performing at us; we were always part of the scene. Yet the majority of the experience focused on puzzle-solving, and there was no shortage of creative mysteries to unfurl.
For escape room enthusiasts visiting Toronto, a visit to Casa Loma is a must, and our top recommendations are The Dragon’s Song and King of the Bootleggers. Yet each of Secret City’s games in this unique venue is fantastic, and especially for fans of the Murdoch Mysteries show and detective stories, we highly recommend Murdoch Mysteries.
Who is this for?
- Puzzle lovers
- Any experience level
- Players who don’t need to be a part of every puzzle
- Fans of the Murdoch Mysteries TV series
Why play?
- An entertaining riff on your usual “detective” escape room
- A bounty of satisfying puzzles
Story
Detective Murdoch had gone missing, and it was up to us to find out what happened… before it was too late.

Setting
Murdoch Mysteries was set in Station House No. 4, the central police precinct from the Murdoch Mysteries TV series. While it wasn’t an exact reproduction, it captured the vibe of a classic detective office, with a stately wooden desk and an assortment of tools and references that would be helpful during investigations.
Gameplay
Secret City’s Murdoch Mysteries was a standard escape room with a moderate level of difficulty.
Core gameplay revolved around solving puzzles, making connections, and searching. While this was a public-booking game, there was plenty of gameplay to go around at any given point.
Analysis
➕ The actors in Murdoch Mysteries were fantastic. They concocted a clear and compelling narrative while also supporting us throughout the gameplay. They were present in-room for the full experience without ever being overbearing or getting in the way of the players. When they needed to step in, their organic style of hinting demonstrated a masterful knowledge of the gameplay, subtly redirecting our attention without ever stealing the solve.
➕ Murdoch Mysteries was packed with a wide variety of creative puzzles. The gameplay was consistently collaborative and tactile, making it accessible and engaging to public-booking groups with a range of experience levels.
➕/➖ For fans of the Murdoch Mysteries TV series, this escape room was packed with numerous references to the show. Yet Murdoch Mysteries the escape room largely still felt like a typical detective’s office on the surface, even for someone like me who saw a couple seasons of the show some years back. I walked away feeling like I’d played a Murdoch-themed escape room, though not necessarily with any added excitement to watch more of the TV series.
➖/➕ Murdoch Mysteries was physically much smaller than Secret City’s other escape rooms at Casa Loma. A slightly lower max team size reflected this difference, yet it still felt more crowded than their larger games, and it would have actually been fully solvable with an experienced team of 3-5 players, unlike their other rooms which have even broader puzzle width. Nevertheless, Secret City designed smartly within their constraints. The small space was efficiently filled with a high density of puzzle content, and the gameplay was designed to flex well for larger teams, ensuring that nobody was left with nothing to do.
➕ Alongside the mostly puzzle-centric gameplay, there was also a fair amount of searching for puzzle components. This searching was tricky, but never boring or random. It provided players, especially those with less puzzle experience, a clear task that contributed meaningfully to the overall mission.
➖ The mid-game point lacked an intermediate metapuzzle that tied together and confirmed what we’d accomplished up to that point. Theoretically, for eagle-eyed players or larger groups, the entire game’s content could be unlocked at once, which could have undermined a later sequence.
➕ A final metapuzzle was elegant, both through the lens of gameplay and narrative. Everything tied together cleverly.
Tips For Visiting
- Arrive promptly 15 minutes before your game’s start time. Since Casa Loma’s escape rooms are public booking, they begin exactly on time.
Book your hour with Secret City’s Murdoch Mysteries, and tell them that the Room Escape Artist sent you.
Disclosure: Secret City comped our tickets for this game.

![Casa Loma Escape Rooms by Secret City – Murdoch Mysteries [Review]](https://roomescapeartist.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/07/murdoch-mysteries-murdoch-mysteries-1.jpg)

![Terror Stories Barcelona – Esoteric Section: Exorcista [Review]](https://roomescapeartist.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/07/exorcista-exorcista-1.jpg)
![Casa Loma Escape Rooms by Secret City – King of the Bootleggers [Review]](https://roomescapeartist.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/07/king-of-the-bootleggers-king-of-the-bootleggers-1.jpg)
Leave a Reply