Professor Holmes’ final exam.
Location: New York, NY
Date Played: January 29, 2018
Team size: 2-5; we recommend 2-4
Duration: 60 minutes
Price: $40-$50 per ticket (depending on team size) on weekdays; $50-$60 per ticket (depending on team size) on evenings and weekends
In the beginning, Sherlocked struck all the right notes. However, Komnata Quest’s interactive style vanished in the latter half of the experience, fizzling into a paper-based observation-and-deduction exam. What started off fun turned into an agitating and frustrating mess.
Who is this for?
- Puzzle lovers
- Sherlock Holmes fans
- Any experience level
- People who want to play as detectives
- To play as a detective
- The escape room puzzle sequences
A politician has been murdered and our dear friend Sherlock Holmes has been framed for it. We broke into the legendary detective’s home at 221B Baker Street in search of evidence to exonerate him.
The flat of Sherlock Holmes was a bright Victorian study. Parts of it felt lived in; other areas seemed sterile and staged. Most of the critical props and set pieces showed signs of wear.
Sherlocked’s set was unusual for Komnata Quest because it was well lit.
Sherlocked felt like two games in one escape room.
Initially we played a traditional escape room filled with searching, puzzles, interesting interactions, and a lot of reading.
When we reached the final puzzle, the tone and gameplay shifted.
The final challenge was a multiple choice test regarding the facts of the case. The correct answers would secure our freedom as well as that of Mr. Holmes.
The opening puzzle sequence struck a chord with us. It was well clued and soundly executed.
The early detective work. The interactive investigating was pretty nifty.
The first portion of Sherlocked, which included about 75% of the gameplay, flowed really well. These puzzles were a ton of fun.
The final 25% of gameplay felt like a standardized test. The gameplay moved away from the environment onto a few sheets of paper. There was far too much to read and some of the questions had ambiguous answers or observational nitpicks. This wasn’t conducive to escape room-style gameplay and it wasn’t fun.
The culminating puzzle sequence involved almost no player action and offered no feedback. Our gamemaster had no means to follow our progress. Any help was clunky at best. (This wasn’t his fault; it was due to the game’s structure.)
The set showed a lot of wear, which was amplified by the lighting. We always try to be respectful players, but especially given the state of the set, we played particularly cautiously… and we got burned by that decision.
An incredibly important moment didn’t reveal emphatically. We didn’t even know that we had triggered something. Komnata Quest could make that open pop so that players don’t miss the moment.
One puzzle invited MacGyvering… but only as intended by the game designer. We were chastised for finding another similar “tool” within our environment.
Sherlocked cost between $40 and $60 per ticket depending upon team size and day of the week. For an escape room with maintenance issues and a lengthy, weak finale, that was too much money.
Tips for Visiting
- For upscale dining nearby, we recommend sushi at Haru.
- For casual dining nearby, City Acres Market offers Vanessa’s dumplings.
- There are not a lot of dining options open late in this neighborhood.
- Parking is a challenge, consider a subway or ferry for transportation.
- Book during the week with a larger team for a more reasonable price.
Book your hour with Komnata Quest’s Sherlocked, and tell them that the Room Escape Artist sent you using the coupon code escapeartist to receive 10% off.
Disclosure: Komnata Quest comped our tickets for this game.