Who gave Uncle Scrooge a vat of lacquer?
Location: New York, NY
Date Played: March 19, 2018
Team size: 6-10; we recommend 3-6
Duration: 60 minutes
Price: $28 per ticket
Despite the uneven clue structure and set construction, we enjoyed many of the puzzles and nifty mechanisms in Secluded Vault. If Mystery Room NYC can remove debris from former puzzles and put a bit more attention into upkeep and cluing, Secluded Vault will deliver a more satisfying experience.
All in all, the fifth installment from Mystery Room NYC was a big step up from chapter 4.
Who is this for?
- Observant players
- Players who enjoy mechanical interactions
- Best for players with at least some experience
- Unusual interactions
Our pursuit of Edwards, the recurring villain at Mystery Room NYC, had led us to a vault. We needed to solve our way past the security to steal a journal from within.
Although this was Chapter 5 of the Mystery Room NYC saga, it didn’t rely on any knowledge of previous chapters. It was only connected to those other chapters in so far as there was a recurring character as the backdrop for the escape.
Those of us who didn’t know the story going in had no idea that there was a story.
The set was an escape room-style office with a few bank-esque nods. A few desks, shelves, and bookcases-turned-display cases were set against barely adorned white walls.
Any decor not behind glass was lacquered down. The entire set felt like a giant still life.
Secluded Vault was an observe-and-puzzle escape room. If we could move or manipulate it, we were going to have figure out how to use it by connecting it to something we could observe.
The clue structure varied enormously. Sometimes Mystery Room NYC told us exactly what to do and sometimes we had to grasp at connections.
Secluded Vault included a few unusual mechanical interactions. We enjoyed these moments as many of them were particularly cool.
Mystery Room NYC thwarted our expectations with one prop that wasn’t used as we’ve come to expect. We thought we had this case cracked, but we were wrong, in a good way.
The reliance on observation of a larger gamespace facilitated teamwork.
Since opening Secluded Vault, Mystery Escape Room had removed some of the puzzles, but left disabled set pieces or props. This created needless red herrings that persisted throughout the experience. It was also a disappointment because some of those props seemed like they should have done something cool.
The set and props lacked polish and showed signs of wear. Some of this wear made the game look beat up; other instances obscured the in-game clues.
There were audio clues that were so garbled that we couldn’t understand them.
Secluded Vault suffered from inconsistent clue structure. At times, it was too direct. Other times, we were presented with unfamiliar objects and expected to intuit connections without any cluing.
Mystery Room NYC remains heavily committed to their ongoing narrative, but it is so loose that it’s irrelevant, missable, and forgettable.
Tips for Visiting
- Mystery Room NYC’s downtown location is accessible by subway. Take the B/D/F/M to Broadway-Lafayette or the 4/6 to Bleecker or the R/W to Prince. There is also street parking.
- For nearby food, we recommend Burger and Barrel (try the Bash Burger). There are lots of options around.
Book your hour with Mystery Room NYC’s Chapter 5: Secluded Vault, and tell them that the Room Escape Artist sent you.